[CLOSED] 2014 Map Competition Listing Top 5 Vote!

The Top 5 Maps (In no particular order)

Map/Scenario Name	Map/Scenario Creator
The Great European War v3.7	Chancellor E.J.R
Arvond 10v10	Columna Durruti
Rise of Rome 4: Second Punic War	Aetius
The Death of Rome	Tunder3/Comrade Jared
Hells GGG:Strange New History	HellRaiserX666X

These 5 will be receiving Protocoins and Trophies (Top 3 only).

Please vote HERE! *click click*


You may all comment with manners below. Thank you.

BEST OF THE REST!

Map/Scenario Name and Creator	Score
Mediterranean (b0nker2)	6.70
Cute's: Fall of Axis Asia (Cute Panda)	6.70
World in 1939 (Ricky Carmichael)	6.65
Hells Medieval World (HellRaiserX666X)	6.50
Empire Medieval (b0nker2)	5.90
Martell's Extreme Roleplay (Prince Martell)	4.27

I also forgot to mention that we got an astounding 44 votes on the closed votes. Lets see if we can beat that on public votes shall we? Post was also made on New Years Eve in Kiribati!

>Martell's RP
srsly guys

Nice

Written by Guest, 30.12.2014 at 16:38

>Martell's RP
srsly guys

Written by Guest, 30.12.2014 at 16:38

>Martell's RP
srsly guys

10th (out of 10).

Wait what did panda's asia map get? I don't see it here.

Written by Camel, 30.12.2014 at 18:36

Wait what did panda's asia map get? I don't see it here.

Opps sorry I forgot about it in the wall of text.

I'm surprised my map got top 5

Bonkers maps best maps

Chronus UN. obvisously, if that vote cant be counted, Martell's RP absolutely.

Written by Al Fappino, 30.12.2014 at 21:30

Chronus UN. obvisously, if that vote cant be counted, Martell's RP absolutely.

lel

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Only 1 of those maps wasn't made from scratch.

Your statement raises one good question:
Is a nice background all thats is needed to be considered a good map maker?

I would feel disappointed if CD wins first place.

Written by Tundy, 31.12.2014 at 00:40

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Only 1 of those maps wasn't made from scratch.

Your statement raises one good question:
Is a nice background all thats is needed to be considered a good map maker?

I would feel disappointed if CD wins first place.

No it is not, but that is a very original map. Why would you feel dissapointed taking aside your own entry, don't rate the map?

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:29

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Don't take this wrong but Public votes are popularity contests, already I have been asked by two of the entrants to vote for their map. It is too open to abuse

Written by b0nker2, 31.12.2014 at 00:52

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:29

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Don't take this wrong but Public votes are popularity contests, already I have been asked by two of the entrants to vote for their map. It is too open to abuse

Well thats the problem public vote system are alway opened to rigging. Its really up to the public to vote honestly and not be bias towards certain maps. I'm always open to ways to improve the public vote system but I never get suggestions, either it is impossible to improve it or people are just lazy.

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:59

Written by b0nker2, 31.12.2014 at 00:52

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:29

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Don't take this wrong but Public votes are popularity contests, already I have been asked by two of the entrants to vote for their map. It is too open to abuse

Well thats the problem public vote system are alway opened to rigging. Its really up to the public to vote honestly and not be bias towards certain maps. I'm always open to ways to improve the public vote system but I never get suggestions, either it is impossible to improve it or people are just lazy.

There is no set of specific things that defines who is a good or bad map maker, contests will be rigged until somebody comes up with a proper standar, because everybody has a different opinion about who's maps are good. (Democracy is evil)

For example, i would put border quality above everything else. For me the border quality and city density within a border is the only thing that matters, could careless of the balance, accuaracy, and fun of the map.

I judge border quality by how complex and realistic it is, if the map is full blown fantasy then its already a minus on my list. (For this reason i dislike CD maps.)

Written by Tundy, 31.12.2014 at 01:25

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:59

Written by b0nker2, 31.12.2014 at 00:52

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:29

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Don't take this wrong but Public votes are popularity contests, already I have been asked by two of the entrants to vote for their map. It is too open to abuse

Well thats the problem public vote system are alway opened to rigging. Its really up to the public to vote honestly and not be bias towards certain maps. I'm always open to ways to improve the public vote system but I never get suggestions, either it is impossible to improve it or people are just lazy.

There is no set of specific things that defines who is a good or bad map maker, contests will be rigged until somebody comes up with a proper standar, because everybody has a different opinion about who's maps are good. (Democracy is evil)

For example, i would put border quality above everything else. For me the border quality and city density within a border is the only thing that matters, could careless of the balance, accuaracy, and fun of the map.

I judge border quality by how complex and realistic it is, if the map is full blown fantasy then its already a minus on my list. (For this reason i dislike CD maps.)

Meh, I feel you are wrong there. Even if the borders are complete crap (which many are on various maps (none of these though)) what really matters is how fun it is to play. It's a game, after all.

When does voting end?

Written by Black Vortex, 31.12.2014 at 17:56

When does voting end?

7th or when we get 150 votes (halfway through).

Gogogogo vote

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:59

Written by b0nker2, 31.12.2014 at 00:52

Written by Meester, 31.12.2014 at 00:29

Written by b0nker2, 30.12.2014 at 22:50

If Columna's map doesn't win out of those 5 then its a bit of a joke. It is original, and unlike most the entries made from scratch. Aeitus 2nd.

Well it is a public vote. Its basically if all 5 of the maps were hosted at the same time which one would the join 1st,2nd,3rd etc.

Don't take this wrong but Public votes are popularity contests, already I have been asked by two of the entrants to vote for their map. It is too open to abuse

Well thats the problem public vote system are alway opened to rigging. Its really up to the public to vote honestly and not be bias towards certain maps. I'm always open to ways to improve the public vote system but I never get suggestions, either it is impossible to improve it or people are just lazy.

public vote is biased, lets be honest the majority of people who vote wont look at any of these maps and base it off the map maker and who they like, so that kinda defeats the point, and seperate to this convo, bonker dont be so butthurt that your map isnt in top 5, just because we dont come up with a "new map" (despite columna's map not being new as it has ideas based in history so yeah totally "new idea") doesnt defeat that these other maps are good maps and a lot of work was put into them, at least with an original map you dont have to spend so much time and work researching stuff, I would venture to say that making maps based on history or past stuff is even more work and even more challenging, and our maps arent copies, even if the idea has been done b4 it is still original work, and I can speak for tunder and my map that I researched everything without using other maps as reference, so stop bitching that we map makers are shit and that you pathetic 3v3ers are so amazing and bragging and shit, yes you made a map and you lost, go cry to mods and players who care

Meester I have a question, does your form track IPs of the votes?

EDIT:

Also what Jared said is correct, at least his first sentence. Wait wtf that entire post is a huge run-on sentence

Rise of Rome 4: Second Punic War

Written by Aetius, 31.12.2014 at 22:17

Meester I have a question, does your form track IPs of the votes?

EDIT:

Also what Jared said is correct, at least his first sentence. Wait wtf that entire post is a huge run-on sentence

its cause i am an illiterate texas

Meester told me he was counting every vote of an account over rank 6...

Written by Quantum027, 31.12.2014 at 22:32

Written by Aetius, 31.12.2014 at 22:17

Meester I have a question, does your form track IPs of the votes?

EDIT:

Also what Jared said is correct, at least his first sentence. Wait wtf that entire post is a huge run-on sentence

its cause i am an illiterate texas

Meester told me he was counting every vote of an account over rank 6...

Or some individual would set up a proxy that changes ip every time the page is refresh. Like for real

Written by Aetius, 31.12.2014 at 22:17

Meester I have a question, does your form track IPs of the votes?

EDIT:

Also what Jared said is correct, at least his first sentence. Wait wtf that entire post is a huge run-on sentence

Yea it tracks IP but like tunder said proxy.

Good luck to everyone may the best map win!